Measuring the success of a student is a very controversial subject. Some say tests are the only way to measure student learning. Others would say that this is not a fair method. Some would argue it is not fair to think this is unfair... and the conversations can go on. This is issue really boils down to the need of your student. There is no getting around testing, the state requires it because it is a known method for testing growth quickly and easily for large groups of people. Now some students may not test well, this when you can take into consideration the other aspects of learning, such as classroom activities. We cannot simply eliminate part of a system because it is not fair to everyone because that is not how it works in the real world we are preparing them for. We as teachers have to adapt and figure how to maximize their individual learning. Teaching the same material to 25 small minds and then individually accessing what they learned and helping each student reach the same goal. This is no easy job for sure. This is similar to asking 25 people to run a race but some have obstacles to get through and some have more obstacles than others and still at the end of the day they must all cross the same finish line. Teachers have to be creative in this approach and provide the correct tools to help each student be successful.
This leads into our next conversation. How to appropriately blend technology, content, and pedagogy. Pedagogy is methods of great teaching. To me this means harvesting success most effectively. This may mean the use of technology as tool to enhance learning but this may also mean the use of no technology. This is not a cut and dry answer. This depends on the group of students, the subject being taught, the mood for the day of the class.. the list can go on. True pedagogy I believe comes when you truly know your students and how they learn best. Each student will learn differently but as a group a teacher has to decide what the best method is to help her class cross that finish line together.
Success is the goal.. not an A, not a 4 on the EOGs, simply success. Harvesting success starts with the teacher and follows through and reflects in the students. Helping your students cross that finish line is the goal. Obstacles will arise but a good teacher, a successful teacher, will harvest successful students because they have learned what success truly is... growth.
Colleen, I really like the comparison you used when you compared teaching to the race because it is so true. Every student has to be ready for the next grade after they leave your class but they all have different obstacles to go through and will all reach the finish line at different times. It is going to be a very challenging process to get each one of your students at the same level but I think after a couple years of practice it will get easier once we figure out what methods work to get to this place.
ReplyDeleteColleen,
ReplyDeleteGreat blog title for this week! I really appreciate the connections you made about the difference between developing knowledge and developing understanding! Practicing teachers need to read this blog. Our goal is success - and this means different things for different students. Keep learning!
I want to mark two quotes I love in your post.
ReplyDelete"Teachers have to be creative in this approach and provide the correct tools to help each student be successful." For me you said the key of evaluation.
"...Simply understanding the benefits of an "off-topic" discussion is a benefit from this week..." I love the way you explain yourself , I think that you have the clearly idea about how to prepare them for life.
Great job!
I really enjoyed your post, Colleen. You brought up some great points! I really liked your statement, "Teaching the same material to 25 small minds and then individually accessing what they learned and helping each student reach the same goal." and how you related it to running a race. That's so true! It's difficult to figure out how exactly to measure a students success, while trying to do this fairly for each student. It definitely requires creativity, and to be resourceful in my opinion…. Great post!
ReplyDelete